Heritage Cigar Brands Draft and Blind Tasting

From Creekside Podcast Ep. 054: Heritage Cigar Brands Draft, aired May 29, 2026. Recorded at Creekside Cigar Co. in Maineville, Ohio.

On this Creekside Podcast, Dave and Conner welcome Felix for a blind tasting, a discussion of the May Creekside Cigar Club box and a much-requested draft of heritage cigar brands. The episode is a useful reminder that a cigar’s reputation is only part of the story: construction, consistency, flavor preferences and personal history all shape how we judge a brand.

What makes a cigar brand a heritage brand?

Before the draft, the crew agrees there is no formal rulebook for “heritage” or “legacy.” They aim to stay away from brands they consider too new or boutique, while using their best judgment about which companies have earned a place in the conversation. That leaves room for disagreement, which is part of the fun.

Padrón goes first, praised for its legendary status, premium pricing and dependable construction. The group notes that not every blend will suit every palate, but the brand’s consistency is central to its reputation. Arturo Fuente follows, with its wide range—from approachable cigars such as the Chateau line to higher-end offerings such as Opus X—highlighted as a strength. Plasencia earns another early pick, with Felix describing it as one of his favorite legacy brands.

The draft continues with Davidoff, Montecristo, Oliva, J.C. Newman, My Father and Ashton. The reasons vary: Davidoff’s reliable draw and burn, Montecristo’s long-standing place in the cigar world, and Oliva’s consistent, sweet-leaning profile all come up. J.C. Newman is recognized for its history and continued cigar making in Tampa’s Ybor City. The group’s different tastes make clear that a strong heritage case does not require every person to love every cigar.

What did the crew learn from the blind cigar tasting?

The three blind cigars prompt very different reactions. One is described as oily and especially shiny, with an early impression of chocolate, roasted chestnut, cinnamon, praline pecan and sweetness. Its smoker initially suspects it might be from La Flor Dominicana, but the reveal is the Pestana Habano Robusto. He says he would pay more than its stated $14 suggested retail price, though the exact amount he names is higher.

Felix’s cigar is a creamy, floral Connecticut that he compares to a New Dawn Toro. He enjoys it and says he would pay the price, but the reveal is the Fario Tego Elegancia. The comparison is a reminder of how strongly familiar blends can shape a blind guess, even when the smoker is trying to assess the cigar on its own.

Dave’s cigar is described as a Connecticut in a Lonsdale-like size, with a gentle profile. He says it did not quite land for him that evening, while acknowledging that he likes the maker’s other cigars. Its reveal is the La Vida Habana Claro. The tasting also brings up practical points: smoking a Connecticut too quickly can affect the experience, and a cigar’s timing, food and drink may influence how it comes across.

What stood out in the May cigar club box?

The May box is built around variety and the crew’s personal enthusiasm for the selections. Dave talks about Principle Cigars’ Martinique Corona Gorda, which begins with citrus and a sharper edge before settling into cake batter, frosting and cinnamon notes. He recalls enjoying it with espresso and cream, and says it has become a regular pick for him.

Conner champions the Absolutos Corona Gorda, describing a medium-bodied, sweet and creamy profile with some spice. The crew does not agree on it: one person finds it can taste soapy, while another likes its versatility. That split is presented as a feature of the club box, not a problem to solve. The selection also includes Crowned Heads’ Creekside Broadway, which the speakers describe as chocolatey and concentrated, plus La Flor Dominicana Reserva Especial and Casa Cuevas’ Habano Limited Edition Flaco. The Flaco’s blend of tobaccos from multiple origins is noted as a reason it offers less familiar flavors.

How do consistency and personal taste shape cigar opinions?

Across both the draft and the blind tasting, the crew returns to a distinction between consistency and personal preference. A brand may deliver reliably while still missing a particular smoker’s preferred flavor profile. Likewise, a cigar can be delicious to one person and merely acceptable to another. Their discussion of My Father reflects that tension: the brand’s scale and consistency earn respect, even as some members say its cigars can feel similar to one another.

The same open-mindedness appears in the blind segment. Felix recognizes a flavor pattern that leads him to a confident but incorrect guess; Dave is candid when a cigar does not hit for him that night. Together, those reactions offer a practical lesson for any smoker: tasting notes and reputation are useful, but they are not a substitute for your own experience.

Key takeaways

• Heritage has no single definition. The crew uses judgment, reputation and longevity to guide the draft.
• Consistency matters, but taste is personal. A respected brand will not be everyone’s favorite.
• Blind tasting can challenge familiar assumptions. The three reveals differ from the guests’ guesses.
• Smoking pace and context matter. The crew discusses how speed, timing, food and drink can affect a cigar experience.

Cigars from this episode

• Padrón: Selected first in the heritage-brand draft; praised for its reputation and consistent construction.
• Arturo Fuente: Praised for offering a wide range, from Chateau cigars to Opus X.
• Plasencia Alma Fuerte Natural, Nestor IV: Felix names it as a favorite; he also recalls enjoying the discontinued Nestor IV vitola.
• Davidoff Late Hour: Mentioned among Davidoff cigars that one speaker especially enjoys.
• Montecristo No. 2: Discussed as an iconic Cuban cigar, with a caveat about inconsistent draw.
• Oliva Serie V Corona: Chosen in the draft; the speaker praises Oliva’s consistency and sweet profile.
• J.C. Newman: Selected for the draft; the crew respects the company’s heritage and Tampa cigar making.
• My Father Flor de las Antillas: Discussed as a favorite from the brand and one of its more distinctive offerings.
• Ashton ESG: Selected in the draft; praised as a cigar the speaker has enjoyed repeatedly.
• Principle Cigars Martinique Corona Gorda: Described as moving from citrus and sharpness toward cake batter, frosting and cinnamon.
• Absolutos Corona Gorda: Praised as a versatile, sweet and creamy medium-bodied cigar; another speaker reports a soapy note.
• Crowned Heads Creekside Broadway: Described as chocolatey, concentrated and enjoyable in its closed-foot opening.
• La Flor Dominicana Reserva Especial: Included in the May club box; one speaker calls it a favorite from the brand.
• Casa Cuevas Habano Limited Edition Flaco: Discussed as a concentrated cigar with tobaccos from several origins and distinctive flavors.
• Pestana Habano Robusto: Blind-tasting reveal; described as oily, chocolatey and roasty, with cinnamon and sweet notes.
• Fario Tego Elegancia: Blind-tasting reveal; Felix enjoys its creamy, floral profile and compares it to New Dawn.
• La Vida Habana Claro: Blind-tasting reveal; Dave describes a subtle Connecticut profile that did not fully win him over that evening.

Shop, smoke and listen with Creekside

• Shop the cigars from this episode
• Join the Creekside Cigar Club for boutique cigars picked by our crew every month
• Visit our cigar lounge at 1381 US-22, Maineville, OH, open seven days a week
• Subscribe to the Creekside Podcast on YouTube and catch every episode