Your cart

Your cart is empty

Shop by flavor

Baking Spice Cigars

Warm cinnamon, clove, nutmeg and allspice, layered over sweetness and cedar.

  • Fall & holidaysSeason
  • BourbonPairs with
Baking Spice Cigars cigars at Creekside Cigar Co.

85 Results

Cigar with striped band on a black background

RoMa Craft Neandrethal Genetic Deformity

$11.50

Unit price
per 

Open box of Crux Epicure cigars with red and white interior
Crux cigar on a black background

Crux Cigars Epicure Connecticut Corona Gorda

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

Box of Domain cigars with a single cigar displayed on a black background
Domain Neutron Toro

Domain Neutron Robusto Gordo

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

Open box of cigars with 'Hermanos de Armas' branding on a white background
HDA Descending Shadows Toro [New Factory] – photo 2

HDA Descending Shadows Toro [New Factory]

from $14.50

Unit price
per 

Cigar box with cigars and a single cigar displayed on a black background
Domain Negentropy Toro

Domain Negentropy Robusto Extra

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

Cigar box with pink cigars and 'El Mago' branding on a blue background
El Mago Miami Art Deco Edition Habano Toro – photo 2

El Mago Miami Art Deco Edition Habano Toro

from $13.60

Unit price
per 

Open wooden box of Cuevas cigars on a black background
Casa Cuevas El Flaco Habano Limited Edition – photo 2

Casa Cuevas El Flaco Habano Limited Edition

from $13.50

Unit price
per 

RoMa Craft Intemperance Volstead VO 1920 George Remus Robusto Extra
RoMa Craft Intemperance Volstead VO 1920 George Remus Robusto Extra
Illusione One Off +53 Super Robusto Box
Illusione One Off +53 Super Robusto

Illusione One Off +53 Super Robusto

from $30.00

Unit price
per 

Wooden box of Phenom No. 3 cigars with visible branding on a black background
Cigar with a FQ Label on a Black Background

FQ Phenom 3 Robusto

from $10.50

Unit price
per 

Guardian of the Farm Cerberus 6x44 Lonsdale Box
Guardian of the Farm Cerberus 6x44 Lonsdale

Guardian of the Farm Cerberus 6x44 Lonsdale

from $10.00

Unit price
per 

Open box of cigars with 'Hermanos de Armas' branding on a white background
HDA Descending Shadows Robusto [New Factory] – photo 2

HDA Descending Shadows Robusto [New Factory]

from $13.50

Unit price
per 

Warped Sarto Toro Box
Warped Sarto Toro

Warped Sarto Toro

$16.50

Unit price
per 

An open cigar humidor box with ten wrapped cigars inside and one uncapped cigar standing upright on the black lid. The lid features a black background with a gold wreath and the text '25th Anniversary' and 'L.
LFD 25th Anniversary

LFD 25th Anniversary

from $22.00

Unit price
per 

Open wooden humidor with cigars and Astronomici logo on a black background
Valacari Astronomia Robusto – photo 2

Valacari Astronomia Robusto

from $14.00

Unit price
per 

Box Of Cigars with a white label on a black background
Casa Cuevas Patrimonio Toro – photo 2

Casa Cuevas Patrimonio Toro

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

El Titan de Bronze Holiday 2026 Edition 5 Pack wrapped in a burgundy velvet ribbon
Valacari Neoclassic Habano Toro
Valacari Neoclassic Habano Toro – photo 2

Valacari Neoclassic Habano Toro

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

El Mago Triunfante Toro Connecticut
El Mago Triunfante Toro Connecticut – photo 2

El Mago Triunfante Toro Connecticut

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

A blue wooden cigar display cabinet with dark brown cigars inside, shown against a solid black background.
Tradecraft Azorian Corona Gorda

Tradecraft Azorian Corona Gorda

from $13.00

Unit price
per 

Surpassion King Of Battle Toro
Surpassion King Of Battle Toro 5 Pack

Surpassion King of Battle Robusto

from $13.00

Unit price
per 

El Mago Disco Maduro Gordo
Cigar with a visible label on a black background

El Mago Disco Maduro Gordo

from $15.75

Unit price
per 

Hand holding a green box of 'Lure Cigars' with a label on a dark background
Lure Cigars Mean Jean – photo 2

Lure Cigars Mean Jean

from $15.00

Unit price
per 

A blue wooden cigar display cabinet with dark brown cigars inside, shown against a solid black background.
Tradecraft Azorian Corona Gorda

Tradecraft Azorian Toro

from $13.75

Unit price
per 

A blue wooden cigar display cabinet with dark brown cigars inside, shown against a solid black background.
Tradecraft Azorian Robusto – photo 2

Tradecraft Azorian Robusto

from $13.75

Unit price
per 

Open box of cigars with green band and visible brand logo on a white background
Oz Family Cigars Maracana – photo 2

Oz Family Cigars Maracana

from $12.50

Unit price
per 

El Mago Speedy Gonzalo Cigarillo [20]

El Mago Speedy Gonzalo Cigarillo [20]

$75.00

Unit price
per 

Night Cap Sampler, five full-bodied cigars on a black background
Night Cap Sampler what's inside card listing all five cigars, sizes and wrappers

Night Cap Sampler

$75.00

Unit price
per 

Lunch Break Sampler, six short cigars on a black background
Lunch Break Sampler what's inside card listing all six cigars, sizes and wrappers

Lunch Break Sampler

$60.00

Unit price
per 

Domain Entropy cigars shown in a light wood box alongside a single upright cigar with a silver and black Domain label, on a black background.
Domain Entropy Toro
Sold out

Domain Entropy Toro

from $13.00

Unit price
per 

A blue cigar box with gold detailing and a single cigar resting on top, photographed against a solid black background. The box is labeled Serino Royale and Robusto Extra.
A single brown cigar with a blue and gold Serino 5 Medio band, centered against a solid black background.
Sold out

Serino Royale Medio Robusto Extra

from $11.25

Unit price
per 

Single Cigar of warped futuro 109
Warped Futuro 109 5 Pack
Sold out

Warped Futuro 109

from $11.50

Unit price
per 

A box of El Tan de Oro cigars, featuring an open wooden presentation box with a single upright cigar and several cigars arranged inside. The box lid displays a large red and gold crest with the brand name 'El Tan de Oro' and 'Redemption' and 'Little Havana' printed on the sides.
El Titan De Bronze Redemption Robusto – photo 2
Sold out

El Titan De Bronze Redemption Robusto

from $16.00

Unit price
per 

Surpassion Valor Toro
Surpassion Valor Toro 5 Pack
Sold out

Surpassion Valor Robusto

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

White box with a cigar labeled "Coroneta"
Crowned Heads Coroneta Habano Earl
Sold out

Crowned Heads Coroneta Habano Earl

from $13.00

Unit price
per 

Hand holding a box of Lure Cigars with a dark background
Lure Cigars Holy Colie – photo 2
Sold out

Lure Cigars Holy Colie

from $12.00

Unit price
per 

El Mago Pepe Toro Maduro Box Press
Cigar and purple packaging with 'El Mago' branding on a white background
Sold out

El Mago Pepe Toro Maduro Box Press

from $16.50

Unit price
per 

The Creekside guide

About Baking Spice Cigars

Baking spice cigars bring warm notes of cinnamon, clove, nutmeg and allspice, often layered over sweetness and cedar. They are a great match for fall, the holidays and a glass of bourbon.

Shop with Creekside

Every order over $100 ships free. Not sure where to start? Take our cigar quiz or stop by the lounge and the crew will point you to a favorite.

Verifying your theme

Oops, your theme needs a little help!

We found a price field that our auto-setup tool couldn't configure.

Our expert team can take care of it. Just click Get Expert Install and we'll send you an email when it's ready!

If everything looks okay to you, you can Ignore this warning.