Cigar Subscription Gifts: How to Give the Creekside Cigar Club

Short answer: a cigar subscription is one of the easiest cigar gifts to get right. You don't have to guess at a brand, a strength or a size. The crew at Creekside picks every box, and a new one keeps showing up long after the wrapping paper is gone. Here's how cigar subscription gifts work, which plan fits which smoker, what each length costs, and how to set one up from our shop in Maineville, Ohio.
Why a Subscription Beats Guessing at a Box
Buying cigars for someone else is hard. Most smokers already have a few favorites, and a full box of something they don't like will sit in a humidor for years. A subscription solves that in three ways:
- Variety instead of a bet. Each Classic box has five different cigars, so one miss doesn't sink the gift.
- Cigars they can't find at a gas station. Boxes are built from boutique brands, limited editions and shop exclusives from our walk-in humidor.
- A gift that keeps arriving. Every box is a reminder of who sent it, and each one comes with notes on why the cigars made the cut.
Classic or Select: Which Plan to Give
| Classic | Select | |
|---|---|---|
| Cadence | Monthly | Quarterly |
| Cigars per box | 5, or 10 (two of each) | 4, or 8 (two of each) |
| Price per box | $60 or $110 | $125 or $230 |
| What's inside | Boutique brands, new arrivals and shop exclusives | Ultra-premium, rare and allocated releases that rarely reach regular shelves |
| Best for | The regular weekend smoker who likes trying new things | The collector or the person who already has everything |
If you're not sure, go with Classic. Five different cigars a month is a great way to find new favorites. Choose Select for the smoker who already knows the big names and would rather get four special cigars a season than a box every month. We go deeper on this in Classic or Select: Choosing a Cigar Club Gift.
How Long to Give It, and What It Costs
You can give as little as one box or as much as a full year. Prepaying a year takes 10% off either plan.
| Gift | Classic 5 | Classic 10 | Select 4 | Select 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One box | $60 | $110 | $125 | $230 |
| Three months of Classic | $180 | $330 | ||
| Prepaid year | $648 (12 boxes, $54 each) | $1,188 (12 boxes, $99 each) | $450 (4 boxes, $112.50 each) | $828 (4 boxes, $207 each) |
A prepaid year saves $72 on Classic 5, $132 on Classic 10, $50 on Select 4 and $92 on Select 8 compared with paying box by box. For a shorter gift, sign up on the regular monthly or quarterly plan and cancel from Manage Subscriptions after the last box you want to give.
How to Give the Creekside Cigar Club
- Pick the plan and box size. Start on the Cigar Club page and choose Classic or Select.
- Choose the length. Pick the regular plan for a few boxes, or the prepaid option for a full year at 10% off.
- Ship it to them. At checkout, enter the recipient's name and address as the shipping address.
- Add a gift note. Tell them who it's from and why you picked it.
- Decide on renewal. Prepaid plans are set up to renew. If you only want to give one year, cancel the renewal from Manage Subscriptions after checkout. The boxes you paid for still ship.
Holiday Timing
Club memberships bill on the 1st of each month, and boxes ship the third week. That means the first box may land after the holiday depending on when you order. Plenty of people like it that way, since the gift stretches into January when the holiday rush is over.
If you want something to hand over on the day, pair the subscription with a sampler. The Coffee and Cigar Sampler ($99) puts seven cigars and a 12oz bag of Scoutmaster Coffee Cigar Blend in one box, and the Habano Cigar Sampler and Dominican Boutique Cigar Sampler are easy picks for most palates. Browse every option in our cigar samplers.
What They Get Besides the Box
- 15% off any cigar that has been in the Club. When one becomes a favorite, buying more costs less. Browse past Club cigars.
- Tasting notes on every cigar, plus the crew's breakdown on The Creekside Podcast.
- Fresh cigars. Every box is packed in an airtight bag with a Valet humidity pack.
- Members-only Discord and monthly giveaways.
Want to see what a box actually looks like? Read Inside the October 2026 Creekside Club Boxes, or see how we price a box against singles in Are Cigar Subscriptions Worth It?
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you gift a cigar subscription?
Yes. Choose a Creekside Cigar Club plan, enter the recipient's address as the shipping address, and add a gift note at checkout. Each box ships straight to them with tasting notes on every cigar.
How much does a cigar subscription gift cost?
The monthly Classic plan is $60 for 5 cigars or $110 for 10. The quarterly Select plan is $125 for 4 ultra-premium cigars or $230 for 8. Prepaying a year takes 10% off either plan.
Does a prepaid cigar subscription renew?
Prepaid plans are set up to renew after the year is up. If you only want to give one year, cancel the renewal from Manage Subscriptions after you check out. The boxes you paid for still ship.
Will the box arrive before the holiday?
Club boxes ship the third week of each month, so the first box may arrive after the holiday depending on when you order. If you want something to hand over on the day, pair the subscription with a sampler.
Does the person need to be 21?
Yes. Cigars can only be sold and shipped to adults 21 and over, so the recipient must be of legal age.
Shopping for the holidays? Browse seasonal limited releases and prepaid Club gifts in our Holiday Cigar Shop or explore picks at every price point in our 2026 Cigar Gift Guide.
