Classic or Select: Choosing a Cigar Club Gift

Short answer: give Classic to someone who likes trying new cigars, and Select to someone who already has a few favorites and wants something special. Classic ships five boutique cigars every month. Select ships four ultra-premium, rare and allocated releases every quarter. Here's how to match the plan to the person on your list.
The Two Plans at a Glance
| Classic | Select | |
|---|---|---|
| Cadence | Monthly | Quarterly |
| Cigars | 5 or 10 per box | 4 or 8 per box |
| Price | $60 or $110 a month | $125 or $230 a quarter |
| Prepaid year (10% off) | $648 or $1,188 | $450 or $828 |
| The feel | Discovery: new brands, new arrivals, shop exclusives | Occasion: allocated and hard-to-find cigars |
Match the Plan to the Smoker
The newer smoker: Classic 5
Someone who's still figuring out what they like gets the most from variety. Five different cigars a month, each with tasting notes, is a fast way to learn whether they lean toward creamy Connecticut, spicy Habano or dark Maduro. If you'd like to start even smaller, our guide to the best mild cigars for beginners and cigar subscriptions for beginners are good places to look first.
The weekend regular: Classic 5 or 10
If they light up a couple of times a week, Classic 5 fits right in. If they smoke more than that, or share cigars with friends on the porch, the 10-cigar box includes two of each pick.
The couple or the smoking buddies: Classic 10
Two of every cigar means two people can smoke the same one side by side and compare notes. It's one of the best gifts for a pair who already smoke together.
The collector: Select 4
The person who's already smoked the big names is the hardest to buy for. Select is built for them. October's Select box, for example, included the Ashton ESG and the Avowed The Vow 11.25. See the whole lineup in Inside the October 2026 Creekside Club Boxes.
The person who has everything: Select 8
Eight ultra-premium cigars a quarter, two of each, is a serious gift. It's a good fit for a client, a business partner or the friend who keeps a full humidor.
Still Not Sure? Three Quick Questions
- How often do they smoke? Weekly or more points to Classic. A few times a month, or only on special occasions, points to Select.
- Do they like trying new things or sticking to favorites? Explorers want Classic. People with a short list of favorites appreciate Select's rarer picks.
- Do they have a humidor? Every box ships sealed with a Valet humidity pack, so neither plan requires one. Bigger Select boxes are easier to enjoy with a humidor, though.
Want help from the people who pick the boxes? Email info@creeksidecigarco.com or stop by the lounge in Maineville, and tell us a little about the person you're shopping for.
How to Give Either Plan
Choose the plan and box size, enter the recipient's address as the shipping address, and add a gift note at checkout. For a full year, pick the prepaid option to save 10%. Prepaid plans are set up to renew, so cancel the renewal from Manage Subscriptions if you only want to give one year. The full walkthrough is in our cigar subscription gift guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is the better gift, Classic or Select?
Classic is the better fit for most people because it delivers five different boutique cigars every month. Select is better for experienced smokers and collectors who would rather get four rare or allocated cigars each quarter.
Is Select worth it for a newer smoker?
Usually not. Select cigars are ultra-premium and often fuller or more complex, so a newer smoker gets more out of Classic's variety. Upgrade to Select later once they know what they like.
Can I give the 10-cigar box to a couple?
Yes. The 10-cigar Classic box includes two of each pick, which makes it easy for two people to smoke the same cigar and compare notes.
What does a prepaid year of each plan cost?
A prepaid year of Classic is $648 for 5 cigars a month or $1,188 for 10. A prepaid year of Select is $450 for 4 cigars a quarter or $828 for 8. Both include 10% off.
Shopping for the holidays? Browse seasonal limited releases and prepaid Club gifts in our Holiday Cigar Shop or explore picks at every price point in our 2026 Cigar Gift Guide.
