How Family, Fishing, and Memory Inspired Lure Cigars

From Creekside Podcast Ep. 067: Don't SLEEP on Lure Cigars, aired Sep 18, 2026. Recorded at Creekside Cigar Co. in Maineville, Ohio.

On this episode of the Creekside Podcast, Dave sits down with Lou of Lure Cigars to talk about the family story behind the brand, its fishing inspiration, and the role cigars can play in bringing people together. Lou’s path into the cigar business began with a meaningful moment after his father’s passing, but his perspective was shaped over decades by family, fishing, design, and shared time. His story is a reminder that a cigar brand can be about more than a blend: it can carry memories and invite people to make new ones.

How did Lou start Lure Cigars?

Lou’s cigar story began when he was 18 and visiting the Florida Keys. He stopped at a cigar shop, bought a handful of cigars without knowing much about them, and later shared one with a neighbor. That evening became his first memorable cigar experience. Back home, he found a local shop, bought a box of cigars, and began smoking with his father.

Years later, Lou asked cigar maker Nimmer to create cigars for his father’s 90th birthday. The cigars arrived after his father had passed away. At the funeral, Lou placed them at the back of the church and invited people to take one. In the weeks that followed, people told him how they had shared those cigars with family and friends. That response helped him see how a cigar could become a reason to spend time together and keep a loved one’s memory close.

Lou asked Nimmer about making a cigar for himself. The first production was much larger than the small personal batch he had imagined, so Lou offered the cigars for sale. A local shop and an online retailer picked them up, and the first run sold out in two months. Lure grew from that beginning.

What makes Lure Cigars’ fishing inspiration personal?

Fishing runs through Lou’s family history. His father taught him, and fishing had already been passed from his grandfather to his father. Lou remembers fishing as a child, from neighborhood lakes to trips with a rod kept in the car. He describes it as an accessible pastime that could bring people together without much equipment or expense.

The fishing theme also shapes how Lure presents its cigars. Lou previously worked as a mapmaker and graphic designer, then spent 12 years in assisted-living and memory-care development. His design background gives him a particular interest in lettering, color, packaging, and visual details. For Lure, he draws on the muted earth tones and nostalgic look of older fishing tackle. The brand’s names and presentation connect that creative work to family, friends, and fishing stories.

That connection is especially clear in the Fat Matt cigar. Lou explained that the cigar was named for his son Matt, who became a cigar smoker after spending an evening with Lou. Matt lives near canals where peacock bass can be caught, and a photo of him with a fish helped inspire the cigar’s fishing connection. Lou said Lure’s cigar names often honor family and friends or draw from fishing.

Why does Lou see cigars as a way to connect?

For Lou, the value of a cigar is not limited to what is in the wrapper. He sees it as a reason to sit down, share a story, and give someone your attention. He described the time spent with a cigar as a small holiday: an occasion to gather, whether with relatives, friends, or a local cigar club. The experience can matter as much as the flavor.

Dave and Lou also talked about the value of making time for those moments in a busy, screen-filled culture. Lou sees a cigar as something that asks for attention rather than speed. A person has to tend it, and that steady pace can create room for reflection. He also values the solitude of a cigar, while recognizing that lounges offer a different kind of connection through conversation and shared presence.

That community-minded view carries into Lou’s definition of success. He wants people to enjoy a Lure cigar and tell someone else about it, and he values having his cigars alongside brands he respects. He also described the encouragement he received from a fellow cigar maker at a trade show as a meaningful sign that he was building the business thoughtfully.

Which Lure cigars does Lou discuss?

Lou mentions several cigars connected to family occasions and the brand’s fishing identity. The conversation is about their names and backstories, rather than a formal tasting review. He also says he is cautious about releasing a Connecticut cigar, because he believes a brand’s Connecticut offering is especially important to get right.

• Last Cast: A Connecticut Broadleaf cigar Lou says honors his father’s passing and birthday.
• Jolly Walleye: A holiday release Lou describes as lighter, with salted caramel notes.
• Fat Matt: A 5x54 cigar named for Lou’s son and linked to his son’s peacock bass fishing.
• Fat Tony: Lou mentions this 5x54 cigar, named for his son, while explaining the name and size of Fat Matt.
• Neo Classic Connecticut: A cigar Lou says Nimmer makes; he describes it as a good Connecticut and says he is particular about that style.

Key takeaways

• Lure Cigars grew from cigars Lou had made in memory of his father and the connections those cigars helped create.
• Fishing, family, and personal relationships influence Lure’s cigar names and visual identity.
• Lou sees cigars as an invitation to slow down, share time, and build community.
• For Lou, success includes making cigars people enjoy and earning respect from fellow cigar makers.

Cigars from this episode

• Lure Last Cast: Lou describes it as a Connecticut Broadleaf cigar honoring his father’s passing and birthday.
• Lure Jolly Walleye: A holiday cigar Lou calls lighter, with salted caramel notes.
• Lure Fat Matt: A 5x54 cigar named for Lou’s son and connected to his son’s peacock bass fishing.
• Lure Fat Tony: Lou mentions this 5x54 cigar, named for his son, while explaining Fat Matt’s name and size.
• Neo Classic Connecticut: Lou says Nimmer makes it, calls it a good Connecticut, and says he is particular about the style.

Shop, smoke and listen with Creekside

• Shop the cigars from this episode
• Join the Creekside Cigar Club for boutique cigars picked by our crew every month
• Visit our cigar lounge at 1381 US-22, Maineville, OH, open seven days a week
• Subscribe to the Creekside Podcast on YouTube and catch every episode