Your cart

Your cart is empty

Club

How to Buy a Cigar Gift When You Don't Smoke Cigars

Creekside Cigar Club box with five boutique cigars and tasting booklet

Short answer: if you don't smoke cigars, don't try to pick one cigar. Give a mix. A cigar subscription or a sampler puts several different cigars in their hands, so one miss doesn't ruin the gift. Here's how to shop for a cigar smoker when you're not one yourself, with a few things to find out first and a few common mistakes to avoid.

Do a Little Detective Work First

You don't need to know much. A few clues go a long way:

  • Check the bands. Look in their humidor, ashtray or car for cigar bands. A photo of a band tells a cigar shop almost everything.
  • Notice the color. Light tan wrappers usually mean milder cigars. Dark, almost black wrappers usually mean richer, sweeter ones.
  • Notice the time it takes. If they smoke on a short break, smaller cigars fit. If they sit for an hour on a Saturday, bigger ones are fine.
  • Ask who they smoke with. A friend or spouse who joins them usually knows their go-to.

If you can't find anything out, that's fine. That's exactly what a subscription is for.

Why a Subscription Is the Safest Bet

With the Creekside Cigar Club, the crew at our lounge in Maineville, Ohio, does the picking. Each Classic box has five different boutique cigars with tasting notes on every one, and it shows up every month. The hard part, choosing the cigars, isn't on you.

Creekside Cigar Club box with five boutique cigars and tasting booklet

The no-guesswork cigar gift

Let the people behind the counter pick.

Five boutique cigars a month from $60, or four ultra-premium cigars a quarter from $125. Ships sealed and ready to smoke.

Give the ClubRead the gift guide

Want Something to Wrap? Pick a Sampler

A sampler is a one-time box of several cigars, which makes it a great gift to hand over in person. A few in-stock picks:

See the full list in our cigar samplers, or read the best cigar samplers for first-time buyers.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Buying a whole box of one cigar. Unless you know it's their favorite, it's a big bet. Save boxes for when you know exactly what they smoke.
  • Picking on price alone. The most expensive cigar isn't always the one they'll enjoy most. Strength and flavor matter more.
  • Going strong by default. A full-bodied cigar can be rough on someone who prefers mild. When in doubt, go medium.
  • Buying accessories blind. Most smokers already have a cutter and lighter they love. Cigars are the safer gift.

Still Stuck? Ask Us

Email info@creeksidecigarco.com or stop by the lounge at 1381 US-22 in Maineville with a band photo or a few details, and we'll point you in the right direction. You can also have them take our Find Your Cigar quiz and send you the results.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's a safe cigar gift if I don't know what they smoke?

A cigar subscription or a mixed sampler. Both give them several different cigars, so they're likely to find something they enjoy without you having to guess a single brand.

How can I find out what cigars someone likes?

Check their humidor or ashtray for bands, look at the brands they post about, or ask a friend they smoke with. Note the brand name, the wrapper color and the size.

Do I need to buy a humidor too?

No. Creekside Club boxes ship sealed in an airtight bag with a Valet humidity pack, so the cigars stay fresh until they're smoked or moved into a humidor.

Is a cigar subscription a good gift for a beginner?

Yes, especially the monthly Classic plan. Five different cigars a month helps a newer smoker figure out what they like.

Give the Club

A cigar gift you can't get wrong.

Choose Classic or Select, ship it to them, add a gift note, and we'll handle the rest.

See the Club plans

Shopping for the holidays? Browse seasonal limited releases and prepaid Club gifts in our Holiday Cigar Shop or explore picks at every price point in our 2026 Cigar Gift Guide.

Verifying your theme

Oops, your theme needs a little help!

We found a price field that our auto-setup tool couldn't configure.

Our expert team can take care of it. Just click Get Expert Install and we'll send you an email when it's ready!

If everything looks okay to you, you can Ignore this warning.