PCA Best of the Leaf 2025: What the Cigar Lounge Award Is and What It Meant for Us

The PCA Best of the Leaf Awards are the Premium Cigar Association's recognition program for cigar retailers, judged by an industry panel and public votes. Creekside Cigar Co. was a 2025 PCA Best of the Leaf winner in the Cigar Lounge category, one of four lounges the PCA named that year. The other three were Oscar's Cigar & Sports Lounge, Smokey Bear Cigars & Café and Stanley Pappas.
You may have seen the award mentioned on our site. Here's a plain explanation of how it works, who else won, and what it meant to a lounge that had been open for about a year.
What are the PCA Best of the Leaf Awards?
The Premium Cigar Association (PCA) is the trade association for the premium cigar retail industry. It created Best of the Leaf "to showcase the premium retail tobacconist industry across the country" (PCA). The inaugural winners were announced at the PCA 2024 trade show (PCA), which made 2025 the second year of the program.
How were the 2025 winners chosen?
According to the PCA's finalists announcement, the 2025 process worked like this:
- In December 2024, PCA retail members were invited to nominate their own stores. 38 stores were nominated.
- Each store submitted photos and videos of its shop, bar or lounge, plus a written summary of why it deserved to win.
- A panel of industry experts judged the nominees on aesthetics, merchandising, humidor selection and presentation, and customer service.
- The PCA named finalists in February 2025, and consumers could vote for their favorite retailer during a two-week window that closed March 6, 2025.
- Winners were chosen by combining the judging panel's scores with the consumer votes.
The PCA announced the winners on April 14, 2025, following an awards ceremony (PCA).
What categories does Best of the Leaf cover?
In 2025 there were three categories, each with more than one winner:
| Category | 2025 winners |
|---|---|
| Cigar Bar | The Cigar Vault (Pacific, MO); Fedora Cigar and Wine Bar (Punta Gorda, FL); Fox Cigar Bar (Gilbert, AZ); Thomas Hinds Sampling Room and Tobacconist (Manitoba, Canada) |
| Cigar Lounge | Creekside Cigar Co. (Maineville, OH); Oscar's Cigar & Sports Lounge (Palmyra, PA); Smokey Bear Cigars & Café (Blue Ridge, GA); Stanley Pappas (Englewood, CO) |
| Cigar Shop Only | Neptune Cigar (Miami, FL); The Leaf Master Trading (Abu Dhabi, UAE) |
Source: PCA 2025 Best of the Leaf winners.
The Cigar Lounge category had 13 finalists, from Kansas and Minnesota to Texas, Tennessee and California (PCA finalists list). Being one of four winners out of that group is something we don't take lightly, and we want to be clear about the wording: Creekside is a 2025 PCA Best of the Leaf winner in the Cigar Lounge category, alongside three other excellent lounges.
Who were the other Cigar Lounge winners?
The PCA profiled each winner on its Find Your Tobacconist page. In short:
- Oscar's Cigar & Sports Lounge (Palmyra, Pennsylvania): more than 3,500 square feet with a walk-in humidor, a VIP member lounge with 24/7 access and private lockers, a golf simulator and a game room.
- Smokey Bear Cigars & Café (Blue Ridge, Georgia): known for its spotless lounge, its 1952 Smokey Bear shop truck, and a humidor kept on a reverse osmosis system with dedicated HVAC.
- Stanley Pappas (Englewood, Colorado): a welcoming lounge with high ceilings, advanced HVAC and a wall of lockers connected to the humidor.
If you're traveling near any of them, the PCA's profiles are a good place to start.
What did the PCA say about Creekside?
The PCA's profile of us reads, in part: "Creekside Cigar Co. redefines the cigar lounge experience with refined aesthetics, authentic hospitality, and a curated selection of boutique and legacy brands." It goes on to mention our seating, hospital-grade air systems, curated music, our glass and cedar-lined humidor, and our quarterly small-batch blends (PCA).
What did the award mean for us?
We opened in Maineville in April 2024, so the 2025 awards came around our first anniversary. For a young lounge, it was a good sign that the things we cared about from day one were showing up for other people too: a clean, comfortable room, a humidor worth browsing, and a crew that makes people feel welcome.
It also meant a lot because part of the result came from public votes. If you were one of the people who voted for us, thank you.
What it didn't do is change how we run the place. Our motto is still Smoke in Good Company. The goal is still for people to walk in as strangers and leave as regulars. The award is a nice thing to be able to say. The day-to-day hospitality is the part that matters.
What does the Creekside lounge offer?
Here's what you'll find at 1381 US-22 in Maineville, per our lounge page and About Us page:
- A glass and cedar-lined walk-in humidor with more than 700 cigars, about 75 percent boutique brands and 25 percent heritage names, plus Creekside exclusives.
- A 2,000-square-foot lounge with comfortable seating and hospital-grade air filtration.
- BYOB, with complimentary rocks glasses, whiskey glasses and frozen beer glasses. We just ask that you smoke cigars purchased at Creekside.
- Open to the public seven days a week. You don't need a membership to stop in.
- Brand nights, release days, socials and member events, and the weekly Creekside Podcast recorded in the lounge.
Hours are Monday through Wednesday 11 AM to 9 PM, Thursday through Saturday 11 AM to 11 PM, and Sunday 12 PM to 9 PM. You can reach us at (513) 630-1044.
Lounge memberships
If you become a regular, our lounge memberships come in two tiers, Silver and Gold, starting at $75 a month. Depending on the tier, perks include access to the members-only lounge, member pricing, members-only nights and brand visits, first access to Creekside Customs, and for Gold members, a climate-controlled cigar locker and a spirits locker.
You can see what's coming up on our events page, and read more about how we think about hospitality in Finding the Best Cigar Lounge in Cincinnati and How Creekside Makes Hospitality Part of the Experience. The crew's recap from the trade show floor that year is in PCA 2025 Recap.
PCA Best of the Leaf FAQ
Is Best of the Leaf a single "best lounge" award?
No. The PCA names several winners in each category. In 2025 there were four winners in the Cigar Lounge category, four in Cigar Bar and two in Cigar Shop Only.
Who runs the Best of the Leaf Awards?
The Premium Cigar Association, the trade group for premium cigar retailers. Winners are chosen by an industry judging panel combined with consumer votes.
Can customers vote for Best of the Leaf?
Yes. In 2025, consumers voted during a two-week window in late February and early March, and those votes counted toward the result alongside the judges' scores.
Do I need a membership to visit the Creekside lounge?
No. The lounge is open to the public seven days a week for anyone 21 or older. Memberships add perks like lockers and the members-only lounge.
Watch more on our YouTube channel, where we record the Creekside Podcast in the lounge every week. Subscribe to see what's new at the Creek.